Home > Garden Pests > Companion Gardening to Deter Pests: Myth or Method?

Companion Gardening to Deter Pests: Myth or Method?

By: Leigh Sexton - Updated: 12 Apr 2013 | comments*Discuss
Companion Planting Companion Plants

The argument for companion planting is not entirely straightforward because there are two quite different approaches to the art of choosing a companion.

Traditional Companion Planting

This is the folk wisdom approach and has been built up and – to a certain extent – verified, over centuries of agriculture. An example of this kind of companion planting is the use of the Three Sisters method inNnative American agriculture to grow beans, squashes and corn by planting the seeds in the same hole. The theory is that the corn grows tall and sturdy and makes a support for the climbing beans which add nitrogen to the soil which feeds the corn and the squash which spreads out around the base of the other plants and makes shade with its large leaves to conserve moisture as well as offering a spiky protection from slugs and snails.

It sounds ideal, but it’s worth remembering that this system was developed in a tropical climate so the corn started much earlier than it does in a temperate one. Here the beans almost always grow faster than the corn! Also, the corn used in Native American growing is dried to make flour, not sweetcorn, so it has a different growth pattern. It is possible to use the Three Sisters method but the results are nowhere near as good as those achieved in the climate and with the seeds for which it was developed.

More usefully, growing French marigolds near food crops has generally been found to reduce pests – this is because their roots exude a substance which spreads through the soil in their immediate vicinity, and which is toxic to certain damaging nematodes. However you do need to plant the marigolds densely for this to work. In addition, whitefly hates the smell of French marigolds and will not come near tomatoes interplanted with the flowers. Beans, on the other hand, can fail to thrive if planted near them.

Strong odours can repel certain pests – so a garden path or border planted with creeping thyme or lavender that is regularly trimmed may deter slugs and snails because crawling over or through it can confuse their food sensors located along their ‘foot’. Both tansy and pennyroyal repel ants by creating a strong fragrance that interferes with the chemical compounds ants use to give each other orders. In all cases though, you need to plant your companion at about the same density as your crop – a few plants scattered around will not achieve the required effect.

Sensitive Crystallisation Planting

This New Age system is based on the work of Dr Ehrenfried Pfeiffer in the 1930s. It is essentially a process of making a chromatogram (separating the components of a mixture and displaying them in a coloured pattern) of different plants. Dr Pfeiffer mixed plants together and then made the chromatograms – he decided that mixtures of plants which formed clear and vivid chromatograms were mutually beneficial, while ones that were dull or cloudy were damaging to each other.

This is simply not proven by any scientifically verifiable method and the brightness of a chromatogram doesn’t bear any resemblance to the way the plants grow together and the suggestions Pfeiffer made were not based on watching the plants grow so he had no evidence one way or the other about the actual performance of the plants. While this system is still used by some biodynamic gardeners who believe in the ideas of Rudolf Steiner, several research studies, including one by a senior researcher at Washington State University, have found no support for the Pfeiffer companion planting suggestions.

You might also like...
Share Your Story, Join the Discussion or Seek Advice..
Regarding using creeping thyme to deter/confuse slugs, the slugs are eating my creeping thyme, and I don't want them eaten!
Csilla - 28-Jul-11 @ 6:04 PM
Share Your Story, Join the Discussion or Seek Advice...
(never shown)
(never shown)
(never shown)
(never shown)
Enter word:
Latest Comments
  • Robyn
    Re: Growing Squash and Pumpkins
    @Freemind - They will happily grow on a teepee type arrangement. They are fine growing up high, you can stablise them if you thing…
    17 July 2018
  • Freemind
    Re: Growing Squash and Pumpkins
    Was given some onion squash seeds. Have four successful plants 3 of which have squash growing on them. I put up sticks because they…
    16 July 2018
  • Kamel
    Re: Everything You Need To Know About Brassica Vegetables
    search for any work i am agricultural engineer vegetables and foods
    22 June 2018
  • ella_TP
    Re: Growing and Using Artichokes
    Artichokes are best planted as began seedlings in trenches eight inches profound, fixed with one inch of fertilizer or decayed…
    26 February 2018
  • Rabby
    Re: Pickling Onions and Shallots
    I've been doing my own pickled onions for myself and my family for 30 years and I di them the same every year . I have about 10 of…
    16 February 2017
  • MrsF
    Re: Pickling Onions and Shallots
    I've done my 1st jars of onions today using 1/2 a 4kg pack of Parrish's onions. I'm using Sarsons pickling vinegar with…
    30 October 2016
  • Silverfox
    Re: Pickling Onions and Shallots
    When making a brine for pickles you need a tablespoon of salt for every pint of water, leave pickles in for no more than 24hrs. 3…
    28 October 2016
  • Pickles
    Re: Pickling Onions and Shallots
    I live in Spain and am having great difficulty in buying pickleing onions, anyone got any idea where I can buy them as I need…
    16 October 2016
  • Ian
    Re: Pickling Onions and Shallots
    Hi, I am in the process of doing some pickle onions. Yesterday I made a brine solution with approx 5 ltrs water and went a bit…
    5 October 2016
  • Minety15
    Re: Pickling Onions and Shallots
    Hi, I've been given a jar of pickled shallots and they are soft, does anyone know if it's possible to crisp them up again…
    30 September 2016
Further Reading...
Our Most Popular...
Add to my Yahoo!
Add to Google
Stumble this
Add to Twitter
Add To Facebook
RSS feed
You should seek independent professional advice before acting upon any information on the VegetableExpert website. Please read our Disclaimer.